Sunday, March 21, 2021

Motivation: Ac-Cent-Tchu-Ate the Positive

A few years ago, a new student was joining my studio and, in our first lesson together, we were deciding which elements of her training should be our first areas of focus. To help identify this, I asked, "What are the aspects of your singing that you love the most?" She seemed confused and asked for clarification. I said, "Well, what do you think you do really well vocally? What parts of your voice do you feel really good about?" She paused for a minute and said, "I guess I don't really know. No one has ever asked me that before." 

To be honest, her answer shocked me. And then it made me sad. This student had been studying singing most of her life and had even completed a musical theatre degree, but no one had ever asked her what she likes about her voice. The more I thought about it, however, the less and less surprised I was. 

I think there is a culture in musical theatre training that perpetuates the belief that you aren't getting your money's worth unless you are being constantly barraged with critiques and criticisms. Instructors may pass out a compliment here and there, but we've been made to think that the real work gets done when we are zeroing in on your flaws rather than building on your successes. 

There are a couple of problems with this. First, it can be discouraging and demoralizing to students if all they ever hear are criticisms. Like the student above, it can give the impression that someone's singing is mostly "wrong," when it may actually be quite proficient. Second, it's just bad pedagogy. 

My friend and colleague at the National Center for Voice and Speech, Dr. Lynn Maxfield, wrote an article for the Journal of Singing in 2019 titled "Incorporating Motivation Into Your Model of Motor Learning." In the article, he commented on the instruction (feedback) that teachers give to their students during voice lessons. He writes, 

"Feedback should focus on summarizing the successes of the learner, rather than drawing attention to failures. While this seems elementary on the surface, I would wager that most of us are listening to our singers with an ear to identifying and correcting what is going wrong. All too often, we then verbalize that list of what is going wrong back to our students as our primary mode of feedback." 

He points out that one of the more popular vocal pedagogy books when he and I were in school is called The Diagnosis and Correction of Vocal Faults. It's no wonder so many teachers feel it is their primary job just to call attention to "faults." But this approach is particularly useless if teachers do not also offer "corrections" by outlining a process toward improvement, complete with measurable goals that will indicate whether or not students are on the right path of skill development. 

Critique without correction is not education. 

Imagine if you took your car into the shop and the mechanic gave you a long list of things that aren't working with the vehicle, but when you asked about repairs you were told, "I'm just here to point out what's broken. You'll have to figure out how to fix it yourself." 

But focusing on what's broken may not be all that beneficial, anyway. As Maxfield describes, several studies indicate that learning improves when teachers focus their instruction on positive outcomes while reducing their feedback following poor outcomes. In other words, students learn better when teachers reinforce their positive attempts rather than pointing out their failed attempts. In one of those studies, positive feedback not only improved learning, but also served to increase the students' confidence and decrease their anxiety. 

It's logical to assume that this approach can work in your practice sessions, as well. Do you tend to pursue what is working or do you dwell on what is not working? If you try something five times and only get the intended result once, do you pick apart the negative attempts or do you focus on recreating the one that went well? 

As it says in Johnny Mercer and Harold Arlen's famous song, studio teachers may facilitate learning when we "accentuate the positive." Students may never entirely "eliminate the negative," but they may make more progress if they can shift their focus in a way that allows them to "latch on to the affirmative." 

Now go practice. 



Sunday, March 7, 2021

Deficiency Motivation vs Growth Motivation ("It's supposed to be hard.")

There is one more motivation-related theme found in Basics of Vocal Pedagogy by Clifton Ware that I'd like to bring up. Ware discusses humanist psychologist Abraham Maslow's theory that there are two kinds of motivation: motivation to satisfy a deficiency and motivation towards growth. Ware writes, 

"In deficiency motivation individuals seek to restore their physical and/or psychological equilibrium, while in growth motivation individuals seek to surpass what they have been and done in the past." (27)

These motivations then inspire actions that are tension-reducing or tension-increasing. As one author describes, "Deficiency motivation is an aversive state of tension that makes the person seek the goals that will fulfill the need, and thus reduce the tension."

The opposite occurs, however, in growth motivation. As Ware writes, "Growth-motivated persons usually welcome uncertainty, increased stress, and even pain to reach worthwhile goals in the process of fulfilling their potential." (27)

Of course, in singing training, one of the primary goals is to build efficiency in part by reducing unnecessary tension. But the kind of pain, stress, and tension Ware describes as part of growth-motivation are the natural "growing pains" of learning and skill development. This may include the discomfort of regularly extending the mental effort and concentration needed to master a skill. It may be the disappointment of prioritizing daily practice when there are other things you'd rather be doing. It also means leaning into the psychological stress of performing in front of others. 

Despite the negative-sounding name, deficiency motivation is not at all a bad thing. I would imagine we have all used singing as a way to restore "physical and/or psychological equilibrium." In fact, I would guess that's what led most of us to pursue vocal studies—because singing, in many ways, allows us to feel most ourselves, brings us comfort, and sets us right again. To be honest, many of us who have given our lives to the serious study of the voice probably don't use singing for that purpose often enough. 

Ware points this out, as well. As he says, "Singing for enjoyment is as valid as any motivation, especially if musical activity makes one's life more whole." On the other hand, he continues, "the realization of one's highest potential in any endeavor will require an inquisitive nature and openness to new experiences, ideas, emotions, and missions...Those who have serious vocal aspirations are typically oriented more toward growth-motivation objectives." (27)

A couple of blogs ago, as a way to find motivation, we entertained asking ourselves the questions, "Do I really want this?" and "Am I willing, TODAY, to do the work that will lead me to become a more skilled and expressive singer, even if I don't see those results immediately?" 

Based on Maslow's theories, we may go even further and ask, "Am I willing to welcome uncertainty, increased stress, and discomfort in order to reach my goals and fulfill my potential?"

One of the greatest baseball movies of all time is A League of Their Own (that's not my opinion—that's just fact), which chronicles the beginning of the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League. In one of the movie's most iconic scenes, catcher Dottie Hinson (Geena Davis) is considering quitting the team, believing that the demands of the sport have become too hard. Coach Jimmie Dugan (Tom Hanks) tells her, "It's supposed to be hard. If it wasn't hard, everyone would do it. The hard is what makes it great."

We all know that achieving greatness is not easy. But it takes a higher level of commitment to truly embrace the difficult aspects of the process, knowing that what is hard is what helps make us great. 

Now go practice. 

Dottie (Geena) and Jimmy (Tom)

Sunday, February 21, 2021

Motivation: Plateaus

In the last blog, we talked about focusing on process rather than product—the journey rather than the destination. As Clifton Ware says in Basics of Vocal Pedagogy, "...when the student learns to enjoy the journey, that is, the process of learning with the detailed routine of practice, real progress begins." (24)

So what do you do when you're engaged in the process but you aren't seeing any progress? 

Ware addresses this situation as well: 
"Students should be forewarned that even the most patient, enjoy-the-process approach inevitably will include learning plateaus, which are periods when little or nothing appears to be happening. Fortunately, frustration can be avoided and long-lasting results achieved by using plateaus as learning time for consolidating and internalizing muscular and mental responses through purposeful repetitious practice." (24)

Call it a plateau, call it stagnation, call it a rut. Regardless, we all know what it's like to be working hard but hardly seeing any noticeable progress. This can be a real de-motivator. 

In these times it can be helpful to remember our previous discussions of the three stages of motor learning. The middle associative/motor learning stage, which is between the beginning verbal/cognitive stage and the final automatic stage, is usually the longest period of the entire learning process. It requires the most focus, the most mental effort, and the most time (which may be measured in years, depending on the skill). It's just a part of learning to go through long plateaus of seemingly minimal progress. 

It's also worth defining what a plateau really is. The Oxford English Dictionary defines the word as, "a state of little or no change following a period of activity or progress." Been there. 

But there is also a second definition of plateau: "an area of relatively level high ground." This definition reminds me of the gorgeous sandstone formations of southern Utah. If you've never done any hiking in Utah's red rock country, you should probably skip school and get down there right away. (I mean, you probably shouldn't skip school. Or...maybe you should.) If you have hiked up to one of these plateaus, you know how much uphill trudging it can take just to get to the level ground. Simply reaching the plateau is an accomplishment in and of itself, one usually rewarded by stunning views. 

When we have plateaued in our technical or artistic development, it's easy to forget how much time, effort, and practice it took to get to that point. It's good to look back during these times to see how far you've come and maybe just hang out a while and get used to this new "high ground." 

Lastly, although we often measure our progress through specific achievements, during the inevitable plateaus, we can shift our goals more toward the amount of time we log working on our skills. If you aren't able to note obvious gains, then celebrate consistently showing up to practice and putting your time in. 

You don't have to set a land speed record every time you go out for a run. But if you keep lacing up your shoes and getting out there day after day, you are much more likely to reach your goals than if you allow the frustration of a lack of progress derail you from the regularity of your routine. 

Now go practice. 



Sunday, February 7, 2021

Motivation: Process vs. Product

To build on the last blog, I found some additional information on motivation on my bookshelf in Basics of Vocal Pedagogy: The Foundations and Process of Singing by Clifton Ware. 

Even though most of the volumes on my shelf made no mention whatsoever of motivation, Ware discusses the topic in just the second chapter of his book. As he says, the information is intended to "focus on information and techniques which allow for constructive thinking that lead to appropriate behavior." (14) Therefore, before he even begins to present the basics of anatomy and physiology or dig into vocal technique, he discusses how to cultivate a mindset that will enable voice building. 

The section of the chapter that is titled "The Goal and the Journey as One," begins with the following sentences: 

"As with any challenging long-term task, the road that leads to success for a singer will be more interesting and rewarding if the focus is on process (means) rather than product (end). Focus on the process means that our energy is concentrated on the journey rather than merely on the destination." (24)

In grad school, I had a professor who often compared elite singers to competitive runners. As she said, both have to engage in extensive training and preparation in order to build their skills so they can put them to use when performing a song or running a race. 

I understand the parallels, but I had to argue that singing a song and running a race have different purposes. After all, the point of running a race is to get to the finish line the fastest. But we don't sing just so we can get to the end of a song. In fact, one way to measure a successful performance may be to what degree both singer and audience wish the song would continue beyond the double bar at the end of the page. 

It's also not a great comparison because singing isn't (or, rather, doesn't need to be) competitive. Sure, when you're auditioning, that element of the "business" may feel like a competition. But when you're just singing (practicing, performing, or jamming along to a recording), you're allowed to enjoy that as much as you'd like. By comparison, the only person who celebrates at the end of a race is usually the one who finishes first. 

As you may have heard in Dem Lab, despite all of the Broadway shows Hugh Panaro has under his belt, he actually believes that rehearsals ("...where the real work happens") are more enjoyable than performances. That perspective really points to a love of process rather a focus that is primarily on the product. It's no wonder he reminded us all to constantly look for the joy in what we are doing, even—and perhaps especially—when we are tired or experiencing a lack of motivation.  

What part of the singing journey do you enjoy most? How can you find some of that joy every time you practice?

Now go practice. 


Sunday, January 24, 2021

Motivation

On January 4th, the University of Utah published the results of the Online Learning Survey conducted at the ends of each of the last two semesters. By administering this survey, University officials hoped to learn how well (or how poorly) we all adjusted to Zoom-based education. 

Based on the data, administrators identified the "Top three challenges encountered when taking online classes." Perhaps unsurprisingly, the number one challenge—experienced by more than half of survey respondents (57.65%)—was personal motivation. 

As we embark on another semester of online learning, this is something we have to address. We can't go on with business as usual when we have identified an issue that has led to struggles for more than half of the University community.

For this reason, I scoured my bookshelf, which contains more than 100 texts on voice, singing, and vocal pedagogy that I've been compiling since my first undergraduate vocal pedagogy class (in 1994!). I looked in the table of contents and index of every book to see if I could find anything on "motivation" or closely related terms. I was hoping to find information specific to motivation when it comes to musical and vocal practice that might be useful in springing us into action and out of the complacency that online learning can allow.  

Disappointingly, the majority of the books had no mention whatsoever of motivation, ambition, or even inspiration, unless it was in reference to breathing. It's a little surprising that all of these volumes devoted to pedagogy, which is defined as "the method and practice of teaching," would not have anything addressing how to motivate students to learn. What good is knowing how the singing voice functions if I can't inspire students to want to learn? 

Thankfully, I did eventually find a few books that discussed the topic, which I will explore over the next few blogs of the semester. 

The first mention I found was in Finding Your Voice: A Practical and Spiritual Approach to Singing and Living by Carolyn Sloan. She points out that when people fail, it's not always because of an absence of training or skill. Rather, it's often due to an absence of desire. She writes, "A lack of desire then becomes a lack of energy and a lack of energy causes our persistence to waver until it finally disappears altogether." (34)

If you are struggling with motivation, she suggests asking yourself this basic question: "Do I really want this?" As it relates to vocal work, I think the question may be, "Do I really want to become a more skilled and expressive singer?" If the answer is "yes," then the next question is, from a day-to-day or practice-by-practice basis, "Am I willing, TODAY, to do the work that will lead me to become a more skilled and expressive singer, even if I don't see those results immediately?" 

Sloan also believes desire is directly tied to imagination, stating, "Most activities in life require an overlapping of desire, imagination, skill, and training." (36) She suggests exercising and honing the imagination so we are better able to envision ourselves with the skill set we would like to possess. In other words, once you have decided if you really want to become a more skilled and expressive singer, you should use your imagination to identify what that may actually look and sound like. As Sloan says, "When you are sure of your intentions and the quality of your desire, the journey will be pleasant and the learning will be easier." (34)

Consider exploring these perspectives if you are feeling a lack of motivation or desire. Ask yourself if you really do want the skills you are tasked with building. Ask yourself if you are willing to work today, even in a small way or for a short amount of time, toward building those skills. Imagine what those skills would feel like and sound like in your body and your voice. 

And then go practice. 

Sunday, November 22, 2020

Sing like there's nobody listening?

There is a well-known quote that many of you have probably heard, in some version: 

“You've gotta dance like there's nobody watching,

Love like you'll never be hurt,

Sing like there's nobody listening,

And live like it's heaven on earth.” 

Internet searches most often attribute this to one of two authors—William Purkey or Mark Twain—but there seems to be some question as to its origin. (For instance, I'm not certain Mark Twain would use the word "gotta.")

Regardless of who said it, I have always found parts of the quote troublesome. Love like you'll never be hurt? OK. Live like it's heaven on earth? Sure. But sing like there's nobody listening? Hold on. 

I can certainly understand what I believe to be the main sentiment of the phrase. When we engage in activities that require vulnerability, like singing, it's easy to imagine that anyone listening may be negatively judging us (whether they actually are or not). This might cause us to become self-conscious and to sing in a way that withholds our true selves or protects our egos. Maybe we'll laugh at ourselves before others can beat us to it, or maybe we'll act like we weren't really trying that hard to sound good, in order to soften the blow of any criticism. 

By contrast, when we are by ourselves, we may feel free to make bolder, more authentic choices. We take risks and act without fear of mistakes. Naturally, this can make something like singing more enjoyable, a more true reflection of who we are, and even more technically efficient. I can't tell you how many students have said, "I sound so good when I'm singing alone in my car. Why can't I sound like that when I'm around other people?"

In that sense, I appreciate the intention of the quote. If we are most free and psychologically unencumbered when we are by ourselves, then it may be a worthy goal to "sing like there's nobody listening," even when we're in front of an audience. 

What troubles me about the quote, however, is that it could also imply that the person singing doesn't really deserve to be heard or doesn't have anything meaningful to say. "Just sing like there's no one listening—people don't really care what you have to say anyway." 

Personally, when I have taken the time to thoughtfully prepare a song, a performance, or even a class lecture, I guess I have the audacity to trust that there is someone who wants—and maybe even needs—to hear what I have to say. Why, then, would I want to imagine that no one is listening to me? If I didn't think that I could sing or say anything worth hearing, then I might as well not waste my time. 

That being said, some people really do have no interest in what I have to say, regardless of how I say it. And some of these folks are not at all shy about letting me know this, either in their words or in their body language. (Did I mention that I used to teach middle school and high school?) Maybe, if my message or my delivery is good enough, I can win over some of those people. But maybe not. Some will criticize me regardless of how I perform. Here's what I do about that: I don't think about those people. I mean, if I'm preparing a lecture, I try to present it in a way that is accessible to everyone in the class. But if someone is determined not to hear what I have to say, I can't do much about that. 

Instead, I create an audience in my head that is comprised of people who are eager to hear me. This audience often includes my family (the family I was born into and the family I have chosen), close friends, and students (some current, some former) whom I know to be enthusiastic learners. These people know me and believe in what I have to offer. They will be rooting for my success but they also will not mind if either my message or my delivery is less than perfect. This is who I perform for, even when none of those people is actually in the room. 

As you are preparing your final performances of this semester, I encourage you to think of who might be in your ideal audience. Imagine those people beaming with pride as you sing, hanging on your every note, and appreciating the depth of all your musical choices. Sing for this crowd as though somebody is listening—a whole room of somebodies who believe you have something valuable to say and who know that your voice is worth hearing. 

And whether or not I ever earn a spot in your ideal audience, I am honored to be one of the people listening to you. 

We're almost there. Let's finish strong. 

Now go practice. 

Some of my ideal audience members.

Sunday, November 8, 2020

What's the benefit of learning classical songs?

As many of you know, the curriculum for anyone taking voice lessons through the Department of Theatre includes study and performance of at least one song in a classical genre (opera, oratorio, art song) each of your first six semesters. For the first couple of years, this tends to involve songs from the good ol' 26 Italian Songs and Arias book. 

Why do we put you through this unique form of torture? Don't we understand that you are theater majors and not opera majors? These are fair questions. There are actually a number of practical reasons it can benefit theater majors to develop a vocal technique appropriate for singing in multiple genres, especially classical. 

First, there are musicals (and specific roles within musicals) that require a vocal sound that is much closer to classical than to contemporary mix/belt. This includes many musicals of the Golden Age as well as some modern shows, like A Light in the Piazza and A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder. 

Second, an increasing number of professional opera companies are adding musicals to their seasons, and they generally perform those musicals with more of a classical sound. Case in point, several years ago, both the Pioneer Theatre Company and Utah Opera produced Man of La Mancha within a couple seasons of each other. Pioneer's production employed a more contemporary music theater sound, whereas Utah Opera's production was decidedly more operatic. Even so, both companies hired several of our department students and graduates for the productions because they had the vocal flexibility to adjust their sound accordingly. 

Third, many opera companies (summer-stock companies especially) hire resident artists or resident ensembles for an entire season at a time. Often, these seasons include shows like La Traviata alongside Pirates of Penzance alongside Hello, Dolly! Singers who understand the difference between classical and contemporary musical theatre technique (and who are comfortable singing in languages other than English) could be hired for an entire season of shows. 

Fourth, singers earning performance degrees are eligible for more jobs if they are able to perform with stylistic authenticity in multiple genres. That may involve singing in churches, temples, or synagogues, singing in professional choirs (like symphony choruses), or even being a singing server in a restaurant. One of my students was a waiter in an Italian restaurant and would often get asked to sing. Pulling off an a cappella version of Caro mio ben always earned him better tips!

Of course, in most of these situations, it's not enough to sing with a classical technique. You also have to have a body of classical repertoire that you can draw upon for auditions. Ideally, this would include at least two (if not five) contrasting operatic arias. It would be even better if these pieces are in multiple languages. 

Naturally, none of this is required of you. If you are only interested in performing music theater, that's fine. Even if you're only interested in performing contemporary music theater, that's fine, too. But it does limit your opportunities to get hired. I'm also pretty certain that performing in classical settings will build your musical and performance skills in ways that will make you a stronger music theater performer. It will also build your contacts in the performance world, and that may lead to additional opportunities down the road. 

How has your singing been this week? Now that we're in the last month of the semester, how will you adjust your practicing to make sure you are ready for your final performances? 

Now go practice.