Sunday, November 15, 2026

Vocal Workshops versus Voice Lessons

As most of you know, I was recently out of town doing a short residency with music and theatre students at Northern Arizona University, where I gave lectures, led vocal workshops, and taught voice lessons. I always enjoy these opportunities, which give me fresh perspectives on what is happening at other institutions and always provide me with new ideas to bring home. 

As my teaching continues to evolve, I become more and more aware of the differences between teaching a voice lesson and a vocal workshop (which some people refer to as masterclasses). In fact, this topic came up recently in one of the voice teacher groups I belong to on social media. In that conversation, there was a stark awareness of just how limiting vocal workshops can be. Part of this is because we have so little time with each student that we can usually only focus on one or two elements of their technique or performance. Some of this is also because a positive change in a vocal workshop (which Lynn Helding calls a “performance shift”) is not the same as building a new skill. Of course, before you can learn a new skill, you have to experience it for the first time. But, before it can be considered an actual part of your skillset, it has to be practiced a lot more than you can do in a single vocal workshop. 

The other reason the value of vocal workshops is sometimes questioned is because they are often seen as a vehicle to display the expertise of the teachers rather than fostering meaningful growth in the students. This has led some teachers to stop doing workshops entirely, while others only agree to teach them after offering lengthy explanations to the participants that any performance shifts should be immediately explored with their own teachers to see if they truly reveal paths worth exploring. 

I guess I sit somewhere in between these perspectives. After all, I teach vocal workshops as part of the ATP Singing Class. In this situation, it is one of the only chances for these students to really get individualized, in-the-moment feedback during the semester (unless they are also enrolled in voice lessons). Even so, I always try to make it an exploration of options and providing perspectives and thoughts for them to consider in their own practice, rather than giving them directives that they are required to incorporate. 

I’m also the one who implemented the joint vocal workshops that we do in voice lessons, where students get to work with someone in a one-on-one situation who is not their primary voice teacher. This can provide singers additional perspectives and guidance. And because their own voice teachers are in the room during the workshops, they can see first-hand what is being worked on, allowing any useful ideas to be further explored in their own lessons. Selfishly, I also just appreciate an extra set of professional eyes and ears to see if they may notice something in my students' performances that I haven’t or if they reveal a helpful tactic that can help my students improve. 

Even so, I don’t think anything can replicate the slow and steady work toward progress that happens in voice lessons on a week-by-week basis. That is where skills are systematically built and refined. It is where multiple paths toward improvement can be tested and tried, and progress (however gradual) can be measured and tracked. As I discuss in Vocal Pedagogy and in the ATP Singing Class, the two things that are necessary for learning a higher-order skill like singing are a qualified teacher and regular practice over time. Voice lessons give us regular check-ins on how a student's outside practice is impacting technical and artistic development. 

None of this negates what can be accomplished in a vocal workshop. But, hopefully, when we really understand the differences between the two, we can set realistic expectations about what each can provide. 

Those of you who have experienced both voice lessons and vocal workshops, what do you see as the advantages or limitations of each? 

How has your practice been going? As we head into the final weeks of 2026, how can you ensure that your practice habits are helping you reach the end-of-semester goals you set back in August? 

Now go practice. 



1 comment:

  1. I have not experienced voice lessons at the U yet and am not sure if that is something I will be able to participate in due to the cost of it but I know what the workshops are like in class. Having more time with a student is incredible. My senior year of high school I was in the senior voice class and there were only 4 other people in class so we all got basically an entire class period to each student. It was the best for me as a singer. I have been working on incorporating SOVTs into my everyday life especially in the morning. Incorporating that has been very helpful in my singing as I feel more open and relaxed.

    ReplyDelete