Sunday, September 8, 2024

Silent Singing

Like clockwork, this is the time of year when a lot of people start to get sick. Maybe it's partly because the excitement of the new semester has worn off, and the workload (and lack of sleep) over the last few weeks is starting to catch up. It's natural that your immune systems may start to lower their shields long enough for viruses to sneak in. And illness catches all of us eventually. 

Of course, when we acquire upper respiratory infections that impact the throat, our voices just won't work the same way as when we're healthy. Pushing the voice too hard during these times may risk long-term harm, so we have to be judicious about how much we're vocalizing—this obviously includes doing less singing, but it also means less talking, laughing, and any other activity that involves the voice. We can think of this sort of illness as having a temporary vocal injury. Just like you wouldn't put your full body weight on a sprained ankle, you shouldn't sing full out when your voice is compromised due to illness. And, just like you will gradually be able to put more weight on your ankle as it heals, you will gradually be able to add more vocal activities back into your day as your body and voice recover from the illness. 

This situation does not, however, give you a free pass to skip all of your practice sessions. But it does mean you'll have to make some adjustments. As I list on the syllabus for voice lessons, there are a lot of things you can do that count as practice time that don't require vocalizing (or only involve light vocalizing). This includes speaking through the text of your songs as a poem (softly or silently); speaking through the text of your songs in the musical rhythm; listening to multiple versions of your songs for interpretive ideas; listening to sections of your recorded lessons or class to reinforce musical and technical procedures; highlighting your music to take note of dynamics, tempo changes, and other musical/expressive directions; and, of course, memorizing, memorizing, MEMORIZING!!!

There is another way to practice that won't tax your voice. I call it "silent singing." As we know, singing involves many different systems within the body: lungs, larynx, articulators, etc. Silent singing is essentially going through a practice run of a song the same way you normally do, engaging all of those systems except the vocal folds. You breathe in the same way (and in the same places in the song), you shape your vowels and consonants the same way, you make the same interpretive choices to tell the story with your facial expressions and physical gestures. You just do it without the vocal folds ever coming together to make a sound. You can even do this while playing a recording of the accompaniment of one of your songs, which will help keep the pacing of your silent performance aligned with the music. It's like lip-syncing a song, except you are still engaging the whole body, not just the mouth and face. 

Give silent singing a try if you are sick, if your voice is tired, or if you just want to shake up your practice routine a bit.  

How has your practice been these last couple of weeks? What is your plan for staying on task all the way up to (and hopefully even through) fall break? 

Now go practice. 



18 comments:

  1. I haven't had this much focus on my voice for like 2-3ish years. Before that with my weekly singing lessons i felt like my voice didn't really need too much time to warm up and so i didn't really continue to vocalize after i stopped lessons. I might do a lip buzz here and there but nothing to this extent. I noticed once i started practicing that my voice felt better and easier to grab and use. I'm enjoying it so far.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Ever since a wise professor informed me of the art of "silent singing", I have used it many times while being vocally compromised! Even if I'm not sick, sometimes it is just nice to focus some practice time on silently working my songs- I've noticed it trains my brain to know where and when to breathe within a piece. In order to stay on task leading up to (and throughout) fall break, I am going to give my practice schedule more structure. I want to try assigning different exercises to my practice times, so I always know what I want to work on before getting there and not wasting time figuring out what to do. I'm setting a goal to memorize my current songs before break as well!

    Hailey Petersen

    ReplyDelete
  3. Quite the timely blog post, Brian! I'm excited to add this new tool to my tool kit :) I have never tried silent singing before and it is something that I definitely would've used before had I known about it. Speaking songs as monologues has always been very helpful for me. When it comes to beats, breathes, and memorization it is super helpful. I'm excited to try it out with no vocalization! I also loved the idea of doing silent singing with the accompaniment of the song as well. I'll be trying this out soon. Also, I find that I feel a bit uncomfortable rehearsing full voice when I go home for breaks so this will be very helpful when I go to Oregon at the beginning of next month.

    Alexa Shaheen

    ReplyDelete
  4. Practicing so far has definitely made a difference in my vocal quality. I think I’ve stayed pretty consistent with my practice schedule, with some modifications here and there. One thing that I’ve found helpful has been practicing with peers. Be them classmates or my roommates, practicing with other people has helped me with memorization and finding the right notes. Practicing consistently has reduced my voice cracking while singing, which I’m very pleased with. I’ve never tried silent singing, though. It’s a practice I’m sure I’ll have to integrate at some point.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Just like many of my classmates' comments, I have not been regularly practicing my voice for a long long time, But I can already feel it getting back to the level it used to be at. I feel this is even apparent in my second class run through compared to my first. I was definitely nervous my first time, and I feel I did much much better my second time. I will continue to try my best to keep up with my practicing even though I have been very very busy.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks for this post Brian! I am a big fan of silent singing and other silent practice methods, sometimes I use them to practice late at night when I don’t want to wake up roommates/neighbors but feel the push to get a session in. My practice has been up the last few weeks, I think because of some deadlines on new rep and wanting to get those songs in front of people faster. I want to keep this energy up, even with rehearsals starting which is when it gets really hard for me, so I am going to set some soft deadlines on pieces that help me assign goals to each piece and get them performance ready a bit faster.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I have used silent singing a lot and my singing practice, especially when you're around other people and you're nervous before an audition or a performance and you want to be able to practice or refresh yourself on your song. I tend to use silent singing before any performance, just so I can make sure I know my music/words. I have also used the silence practicing technique with acting a lot as well with monologues by just saying it to myself very quietly or just voicing it in my head and going through the actions mentally and it helps me prepare and memorize pieces . I got sick through these last weeks and I had to practice while I was sick. My sickness didn't affect my voice, but I kept up with my practices, and if there was a sickness that I had that affected my voice, I would definitely try silent singing.I have never done it while I am sick, I have just only ever used it while I was fine.

    ReplyDelete
  8. My practice this last couple of weeks have been very, very crazy. While I have been able to do at least 20 minutes each day it is still wild because they are in the wildest of places. The reason why is because of some personal matters and the show I have practices in a Choir warm up for a calibration of life for a friend to in-between scene in robin hood rehearsal. My play is to still stay on task no matter what life throws at me because even bad practice is better than no practice.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thank you for this blog, Brian!

    I feel like a lot of times I sing a little too much full out instead of focusing on specific goals during my practice. It typically varies session to session but there are a lot of times more than others that I will just sing sing sing my songs. I still break down parts of them and focus on different aspects of my technique, but overall for keeping my vocal health in check and maintaining a healthy work style that isn't focused on results and more focused on improvement.

    I have done pretty well in vocalizing myself in the mornings and throughout the day to the point where my evening sessions are very warm and sound great. I've been working on some agility stuff which as you know is my biggest area I want to improve, and also looking deep into the accompaniment of my pieces to analyze how the voice and piano go in tandem, oppose, or compliment each other. I definitely need to try the silent singing as I just watched the Utah Archers win a championship and traveled to Logan for the Utes yesterday, and I know you want me to make sure I maintain healthiness with all of that excitement. For keeping consistent, I need to try and get into those practice rooms every day. Sometimes I get fed up and just sing in my room but with a piano in front of me I do a lot better. I will keep warming up every day, keep being proactive in studying my music, and keep myself motivated with goals in mind.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Very interesting and helpful blog post, professor!

    I know that at times I am 100% guilty of working myself into a sickness, or not practicing while I am under the weather, due to throat and voice pains. The idea of silent singing is a new, but very helpful idea for me! I had already employed the strategy of listening to my accompaniment and imagine I am singing, or further familiarize myself with the lyrics and song, but silent singing is no doubt another valuable asset I will now have in my arsenal. Thank you very much professor, and I hope the weekend has been treating you well.

    Thank you!
    Tom

    ReplyDelete
  11. Practice tends to be frustrating for me. I don't like being bad at things. Ideally, I'd like to skip the whole "I'm new at this, and I suck at it" part, and I'd like to just be really good at things. Thus far, life hasn't really worked out that way. In my practice, I need to remind myself that if I give up during the "Holy shit, I suck" phase, I'll never actually get to the "Okay, I'm pretty good at this" phase. This semester I'd like to, and hopefully will, continue to work through the shit and come out the other side rather than throwing my hands up in the air, smashing the piano, snapping the music stand, and never singing again.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Silent singing is actually a really interesting technique. I definitely lip synch a lot, but rarely have I gone the extra mile and done silent singing. I will definitely add that into my practice especially when my voice needs a break. Practicing singing has been both enjoyable and frustrating. It is hard to allow myself to go slowly and do the correct vocal warmups and cool downs, but as I have stuck with it I have noticed that it has become easier and more second nature. My hope and plan is to continue pushing through even when I get frustrated and work on consistency over perfection.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I HATEEEEE getting sick, and when I do get sick I definitely try to push my voice further and harder than is probably healthy. I really apprecate the addition of silent singing; I've never thought that could be beneficial. I always assumed that, in order to be learning, you had to be making noise. Yay! My practice has been going well, and it's seemed to be more of a playful thing than a chore recently. I enjoy redoing our recordings from class.

    ReplyDelete
  14. This post is quite relevant to me!
    As you know, the last couple weeks have been a journey with getting through covid and recovering. The first thing to go and the last thing to be fully restored was my voice. In the last week and over this weekend I have been able to practice much more and phasing into it slowly was definitely vital for me. Right when I was able to return to my show, my double came down with covid and I had to cover his shows, doing eight shows this week right after getting over my sickness. I really had to pace myself and in my practice it was lots of lip buzzes and easy onset exercises designed for sick/tired voices and that was very necessary. During my shows I had stage management boost my mic so I didn't have to strain during my singing and definitely was very mindful of pacing myself vocally throughout the shows.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I love the concept of silently singing through songs. That's something I've done for years just by being a dramatic theatre kid in the middle of the night with my headphones in, so I'm glad to know it's an actual helpful concept! I’m still struggling to get into the rhythm of practicing regularly, but I’ve tried to spend enough time doing proper warm ups and exercises we’ve gone over in class. I think the best way for me going forward up through fall break is to just do a little bit every day, even if it’s a light warm up with one exercise. I also spend a lot of my time listening to my song and recordings and thinking through things rather than strictly singing. I find it helpful to listen to myself doing specific exercises because I knew how it felt, but I never have the best gauge in the moment of how it actually sounds. Hopefully practicing should become even more consistent up and through fall break!

    Aurora Nelson

    ReplyDelete
  16. This post could not have come at a better time! The week before our last lesson, I was sick with a wicked cough that I could not shake, and I never even thought about silent singing as an option! Of course, healthy habits create a healthy atmosphere, so I will definitely be utilizing these when I (inevitably) get sick again! I plan to keep memorizing sheet music and listening to the recordings made for me during lessons to keep productive, and when I am sick, plan to include silent singing (which is also not a bad idea for those with neighbors you need to keep quiet for). Overall, consistency is one thing I really need to work on this semester and I hope to keep it up!

    ReplyDelete
  17. Silent singing is a interesting technique! I'll have to give it a try, especially if I am ever sick. Practice has been good but I could be more consistent with it honestly. I think I need to readjust some timing to with certain days. With this last song performing in class it made it clear to me how much more I can improve if I am consistently practicing, so I'm gonna make that a bigger focus in my spare time moving forward!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Whenever I get sick I feel like my voice is gone forever and it feels like I have to relearn everything so I think that silent singing will be very beneficial to me because usually after being sick and not using the body for some time it takes a minute for me to get more comfortable with my singing voice. I need to set reminders! I really need to write everything down that I have to do for classes so I don't forget due dates and other information. My goal this week is to find a system that works with me and my schedule with school and work to get everything planned out. I start Spring awakening this week so keeping up on the practicing and staying fresh with my voice is gonna be much needed.

    ReplyDelete