Sunday, August 17, 2025

Resolve, Part 1

Welcome to the new school year! Here we go...

Let me state something obvious: If you want to improve your skills, you have to practice. It doesn't matter if the skill you want to improve is yoga, archery, skateboarding, or singing—a crucial element is consistent, quality practice. 

Quality practice, however, can be difficult to accomplish. This first obstacle is just motivating ourselves to do it. The second obstacle is knowing how to practice in a way that will actually lead to results. Authors Janice L. Chapman, Ron Morris, and James Platt refer to practice as “The Dreaded ‘P’ Word” in their book Singing and Teaching Singing: A Holistic Approach to Classical Voice (Plural Publishing, 2023). They point out that both student and professional singers can be confused about how to practice, which often leads them to avoid it entirely. In Practicing for Singers: A Guide to Solid Practice Habits, author Joanie Brittingham states, “We singers often don’t practice because practice intimidates or frustrates us.”  Because of this, she believes that many singers give up before they are really able to make technical progress, resorting to repeatedly running through their songs, which can just solidify the errors and inefficiencies that already exist. 

To address this, last year I wrote an article for the Journal of Singing called "The Four Rs of Effective Practice: Resolve, Repeat, Refine, Reinforce." This semester, I'm going to examine each of these aspects to see how they might help us find ways to engage in meaningful practice that will help us reach our goals. 

The first "R" of effective practice is "resolve." Since this word can be defined a couple of different ways,  I'll focus on the first definition for now. As I blogged last January, according to Dictionary.com, when resolve is used as a noun it is defined as "A resolution or determination made, as to follow some course of action; firmness of purpose or intent; determination. Synonyms: decision.” Essentially, the first element of effective practice is that we have to decide/resolve to do it. That may seem like a no-brainer and not that hard to accomplish. But for real progress to occur, we have to resolve to practice regularly and consistently, which can be difficult to commit to when schedules gets busy or when we just don't feel like doing it. 

As stated, resolve also requires determination and firmness of intent. Meaningful practice takes effort and planning (we'll get more into this in the next blog). Therefore, we don't just need to commit to practicing, we have to commit to effortful practicing. This doesn't mean physically effortful, where you engage in excessive tension or muscular hyperfunction. This refers to cognitively challenging practice where you set yourself tasks that are just a bit beyond your capabilities. This sort of practice, where success is perpetually just out of reach, can be frustrating and forces us to dig deep (to find our "resolve"). But this is the sort of practicing that leads to the most beneficial results. There is a reason these tasks are referred to in the motor-learning literature as "desirable difficulties." 

So, as a first plan for the semester, we can resolve to practice regularly and consistently by making a practice schedule and sticking to it. We can also resolve to make practice meaningful by giving ourselves clear goals, challenging tasks to help us build skills (I can help come up with these), and seeing each practice session through. Understanding that these sessions will often be difficult and frustrating, we can resolve to complete them anyway. 

For this first blog of the year, identify some of the goals you have for your singing, whether that's related to sticking to a practice schedule, identifying technical or expressive capabilities you'd like to develop, or any other aspect of your singing that you'd like to see improve this semester. 

Let's have a great year.

Now go practice. 


18 comments:

  1. This was a great blog to start the year off with. In these early weeks of setting intentions and goals, I do well. But after some time, I find it easy to slip up and just "skip a day"...which turns into weeks. Doing it even on days I may not want to, I will never regret that- I'll simply regret it if I don't. This year, I want to identify who I want to be seen as in the industry. I want to work on my rock sound, using the skills I have from musical theatre work, and this means taking risks and experiencing new sounds, even if they sound bad. Girls are always told to be soft and pretty, but I want to be more courageous and not worry about sounding "pretty" all the time.

    Hailey A. Petersen

    ReplyDelete
  2. The idea of reframing practice as a decision versus a flexible thing is an important distinction to make. Practice as such an option and easy feel to it, acknowledging that practice can be hard and difficult to accomplish makes it feel a little bit more achievable. This year I think I want to focus more on failing. That sounds weird, but I’ve heard a lot about the idea of a beautiful failure. Thea idea that I doesn’t have to be perfect but it does have to be. That means adventuring outside of my comfort zone and not have to sound perfect, bu while increasing my range is one of my broader goals for this year.

    ReplyDelete
  3. First blog of the semester! So so profound as always Brian. I love this idea of consistent practice but also challenging ourselves. I think by giving ourselves something difficult, it makes us more motivated to actually want to achieve it (well it makes me motivated haha). A huge goal I have for the semester is truly to stay consistent, to stick to a practice schedule. I find myself getting rushes of motivation every now and then, but then I end up using the excuse of “Skipping a day of practice won’t hurt” but it does hurt actually. This pushes me into a cycle of thinking I can keep pushing my practice back, which for me, drags my progress. Another big goal I have this semester is to not be afraid. I know we talked about it in our lesson very briefly but taking risks and to acknowledge all of the sounds that come out of my mouth with love and care! I am so excited for this semester and to continue to learn from the ways of The Brian Manternach. Wahoo :D

    ReplyDelete
  4. The main goal I have surrounding my singing this semester is to improve upon the gap in my range between my chest and head voice. If I can begin to bridge that gap by developing 1-2 warm-up or practice techniques that can smooth this transition then I can walk away from this class with something to continue working on as I go forward. Other than that I would also like to establish a strong practice schedule that I can keep to and would like to commit to more than 20 minutes at least once per week.

    Stevie Anson

    ReplyDelete
  5. My main goal for this semester singing wise is to just fall in love with it again. I have been taking voice lessons for years and years, and somewhere along the way it became so much more about practicing and sounding perfect, aiming for the product rather than enjoying the creation of it. Because of this something that used to fill me with so much joy slowly became a burden. Even while singing in class this last time, just focusing on how it feels vs how it sounds I found myself enjoying even more. The idea that the amateur singers enjoyed and found more joy in it than the professional singers is something that stuck with me- so, in a way, I would like to become more of an amateur again :)

    Jami Greenburg

    ReplyDelete
  6. The main goal that I have with my singing this semester is to gain a better understanding of my voice and where it comes from. I have never taken a voice lesson in my life, so this is all very new to me, but also very exciting. I think that the main warmups will help me, and my goal is to stick to my practice schedule and use the warmups that we have had in class to gain this understanding of my voice. I want to stick with 20 minutes in the morning everyday that we do not have class, as I feel like that is more than achievable for me if I put my mind to it. Another goal I have is to gain confidence using my voice, as I am confident right now that I am not a good singer nor that my voice in general is very pleasant.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hi Brian! First blog of the last year .. what. The. Heck. I totally agree that quality practice is the hardest to achieve. I find myself after practice sessions just feeling grateful to have done anything at all. I am hoping to shift this mindset this year to one that is more structured and related to the goals I am hoping to achieve and not applauding myself for the bare minimum. With this being my last year, I am hyper-focused on building lasting habits that I will be able to take with me into the world post graduation; effortful, quality practice falls into this category. This year, I am hoping to bring even more vulnerability into a room. In every way; whether it’s expressing joy, sadness, anger, excitement, etc..I want to open myself up especially in lessons. Additionally, I would love to work on my rock sounds like growls and making sounds that I never have before. That said, I want to hone in even more on what I find my strengths to be in order to present most genuinely to the industry and agents when that comes around. I can’t wait for another great year of lessons with you!

    Alexa Shaheen

    ReplyDelete
  8. I have two main goals for singing this semester. The first is to really commit to practicing and to do all I can to improve. When I am practicing I often find myself getting frustrated and giving up or choosing to just run through my songs over and over again without any thought. This semester I want to follow the schedule I set for myself and really focus on what I need to work on. This semester I would also like to find the joy in singing. It was something I used to really enjoy but I now see it as something scary, something I have to be perfect at to do so why even try. I want to change my mindset towards singing and find that joy again.

    ReplyDelete
  9. AHHH Senior post! There are times this past week where the senioritis has really been hitting, but I've noticed that will truly not get me anywhere. With all of my open space within this semester's schedule, I actually have found myself practicing a lot more than I have in the past. It felt the exact same way over the summer. We talked in our last lesson about things to improve upon, and that included tings like stability, vocal agility, and riffs. Granted the practicing riffs has been quite a challenge for me, I've been working to steadily improve. The truth is, I've always had a hard time actually pushing myself to actually start any project in my life, no matter what it is, always procrastinating until the last minute and then lamenting my results. I had a huge realization this summer about how that actually stresses me out more pushing it off rather than just doing the things I need/want to do in the first place (shocker I know). With that framework in mind, I really want to buckle down and put in that resolve and effort to finish out my schooling on a high note.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I'm excited to challenge myself. I'm honestly not sure what goal to persue, but I feel like I wanna have a clearer picture of what my limitations are and what I simply cannot do without damaging my voice so I am able to work the best I can within those guidelines. Having a clear schedule is gonna be important. I'm going to struggle a bit once rehearsals start but I'll still try and see what I can do and how to meet the requirements.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I am so excited to be taking singing this year! One of the biggest goals for me is to really try to keep myself accountable with a practice schedule. I have always struggled getting myself to do be productive and a big part of maturing has been figuring out what works best for me to overcome these challenges. Having a specific rehearsal schedule and having a school assignment behind it is a much better strategy for me than simply knowing that I should practice. I also want to do better this semester at building the habits of a good practice, as you mentioned in the blog, doing the same thing over and over again is technically practice but it also runs the risk of forming bad habits.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Right off the bat, I can totally agree with the quote from Joanie Brittingham about how practice can not only intimidate you beforehand but it can also infuriate you. While I do not practice singing yet, I do continue to consistently practice keeping my health and body in great shape. This refers to the gym. I regularly go to the gym and do my usual weekly routine: Back and shoulders, Legs, Chest and arms, and finally core and abs. Although it is the same repetition, I find myself feeling a sense of confidence in doing my workouts but that also means that I'm not conclusive in that I'm getting the best results which concerns me. Some times if I'm too busy in the week to go to the gym, I'm not only disapproving of my resolve but it also overwhelms me with deep concern and a bit of frustration in my body if I keep missing days. This part of my "practice" falls under the first of the four "R's" of effective practice. While I make the conscious decision to better myself, It feels as if my determination wavers a bit more than I would like it too. Using this as an example, I would like to make sure I have quality time management in making sure my singing ability is well practiced with an improving unique set of vocalizations and tools which in turn, will feed my determination with a more centered focus; like a car needs it's weekly maintenance, you must never forget the importance.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Since I have almost no singing experience whatsoever, some goals I have for myself include proper breath control, learning how to patch pitches, and building confidence to sing in front of others. In order to do so I’ll schedule practice times every day, whether that includes actual singing or just research to learn a deeper understanding of what elements create singing, like notes, pitches, and more.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I have a couple goals for singing this year. For starters, I want to really build more technique; specifically when connecting my chest, head, and falsetto voice. In the same strain of technique, I want to continue working on my breath work. Hitting extended/higher notes more sustainably is a major goal for me. I also just want to keep developing my own singing voice. To stop mimicing/recreating others art.

    ReplyDelete
  15. CONGRATS ON BEING PUBLISHED! Oh man. A goal I have for the upcoming semester is to not practice in the car every day. I took voice last semester, and while I was able to stick to my practice schedule for the most part, I largely only sang in my car. That was the most convenient time for me to practice because I am (unfortunately) a commuter, but it led me to form some bad habits like oversinging and a lack of proper posture. Practicing outside of the car is more intentional as well, which helps me to get into the appropriate mindset for meaningful practice. In addition to this, I need to be better at being wrong. I tend to overcompensate for things when I feel lesser-than, and when it comes to singing, that usually means I turn to bits or weird riffs/opt-ups to cover up a lack of technique. I am so excited for voice this semester!

    ReplyDelete
  16. I think that I could go into this semester with a goal of committing to my practice schedule and making sure I stick to the times I set aside, never missing a day. That is something that in and of itself would stretch me outside of my comfort zone and be something I have never managed to do before. Even with all that said, knowing that committing to practice is an excellent goal, I want to take it a step further and make my goal to want to practice. I want to be a person who strives for excellence. I want my technique and knowledge to improve over time, and I want to actually see progress. I have settled for being pretty good naturally in the past, but I know I can be better, and I want to learn to not only be committed to rehearsing, but invested as well, because I know that the outcome will make me proud of myself.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I am SO excited to be SO BACK this semester with the pedagod. I am already really liking the idea of the 4 R's and I resonated very deeply with the idea that lots of singers, even seasoned professionals, fall into the trap of repeatedly running through their rep again and again, just for the sake of getting reps, and writing it off as practice. Truthfully, that was a habit I feel that I formed last year in hindsight and while I did see progress in my voice, I think it could have been more effective to specifically target areas of improvement during specifically blocked out practice time to refine my technique rather than running things to death, only solidifying habits. I'm excited to push myself with NEW rep, tackling it in a NEW way that is less focused on repetition and more on targeted work!
    Alec

    ReplyDelete
  18. I think deciding to practice is already getting over a massive hurdle, but deciding WHAT to practice and what your specific goals of that session are is the key to actual growth. I really like the phrasing you use of “where success is perpetually just out of reach.” My biggest (yet small in how they’re specific) goals for this semester when it comes to practicing is to relieve throat tension/effort through utilizing resonance more. This problem often occurs for me when I am working my mix, which is also a major place of improvement for me; I would like to make the blend between my chest, mix, and head voice easier to navigate through and to sound more tonally similar. How? I’m not completely sure, probably has something to do with practicing.
    Super excited to come back to voice lessons, I miss singing with Brian!

    ReplyDelete